1. Mediaite
  2. Gossip Cop
  3. Geekosystem
  4. Styleite
  5. SportsGrid
  6. The Mary Sue
  7. The Jane Dough
  8. The Braiser

NYT Slams Wall St. Protest, Calls it “Pantomime Progressivism” — Fair?


It’s clear that the “Occupy Wall Street” movement wanted more press. I’m just not sure that an article published today is what they had in mind.

In a blisteringly critical piece entitled “Gunning for Wall Street, with Faulty Aim,” the New York Times gives a brutal assessment of the Wall Street protests over the last week (as though the title of the article wasn’t obvious enough).

The criticisms range from the protest’s purported lack of members…

According to the group, 2,000 marched on the first day; news outlets estimated that the number was closer to several hundred. By Wednesday morning, 100 or so stalwarts were making the daily, peaceful trek through the financial district.

… to the purported lack of knowledge of economic principles among the crowd:

Some said they were fighting the legal doctrine of corporate personhood; others, not fully understanding what that meant, believed it meant corporations paid no taxes whatsoever. Others came to voice concerns about the death penalty, the drug war, the environment. Having discerned the intellectual vacuum, Chris Spiech, an unemployed 26-year-old from New Jersey, arrived on Thursday with the hope of indoctrinating his peers in the lessons of Austrian economics, Milton Friedman and Ron Paul.

Intellectual vacuum. Ouch.

But is this a fair assessment? Occupy Wall Street’s effort has been met with some praise by those disillusioned with the economic status quo — and if there were ever a time to be fed up with said system, this might be it. That being said, the relatively modest size of the protest (coupled with some members’ outsized demands for press) does make one wonder if this was more dud than revolution. And, while we’re on the subject, the protesters’ attempt to ally themselves with the Egyptian uprising (at least in their rhetoric) seems almost entirely tone-deaf and narcissistic.

Even so, the protests have been met with some cruel, cringe-inducing derision, the kind that’s entirely unwarranted and only bolsters their mission. One expletive-laden Facebook post yesterday (from an alleged finance worker) suggested that Wall Streeters were planning to hose down the protesters with champagne, in an apparent effort to highlight what refined, privileged individuals they are. John Hughes’ villains could take a lesson.

One Mogulite commenter claimed that the Facebook post was “a JOKE.” The kind of joke that gets picked up by The Washington Post, apparently.

So — is Occupy Wall Street a revolution? Or an exercise in futility?

TAGS: | | | |

  • Anonymous

    “So — is Occupy Wall Street a revolution? Or an exercise in futility?”
    The commentor who mentioned the champagne toast was a joke was the first coverage I heard about it since it was purportedly supposed to happen, it only took me 25 minutes to find.

    Also, it was the first time I had ever heard of Mogulite. If futile, I’d suggest its a futility which might be working for you. If you care to cover the story.  

  • Anonymous

    Good luck to those marchers today. Hopefully you’ll be there as of 15 minutes ago, covering it? 

  • frustrated ny-er

    I live in downtown NYC. I have been hearing and seeing marchers and have been unable to find any media coverage on my usual news sources. Helicopters, sirens, police vehicles, stopped traffic. And “What’s Happening in my neighborhood” on my supposed local news station and website is weather and traffic and arts festivals.  Finally learned that what I’m seeing is part of the Wall Street take over protest. It looks, sounds and feels REAL to me. This lack of coverage has made me a news revolutionary.  NO MORE NY TIMES. NO MORE NY 1. NO MORE MASS MEDIA. Pulp, all

  • David Sulik

    Sounds like time to march on the NYT for bullshit journalism!

  • Doves Peace

    1- GO NOW, IMMEDIATELY. QUIT YOUR JOB, KISS YOUR GF
    GOODBYE AND START
    YOUR WAY.
    CLICK HERE FOR RIDESHARE: https://www.facebook.com/pages/Carpool-to-Occupy-Wallstreet/222614057794752?sk=wall

    2- SUPPORT THEM WITH MONEY AND/OR SUPPLIES – PEOPLE ARE BEING BRUTALIZED
    BY THE NYPD – THEIR FREEDOMS ARE BEING SQUASHED AND YET – THEY REMAIN
    PEACEFUL – SUPPORT THEM 100%
    https://www.wepay.com/donate/99275

    3- SUPPORT THE MEDIA TEAM, THEY HAVE BEEN ARRESTED AND HAD TROUBLE WITH
    RECHARGING BATTERIES AND RAIN – HELP THEM OUT!!!  2 MEDIA TEAMS WERE
    TARGETED TODAY – PLEASE HELP THESE GUYS OUT – THEY ARE REAL LIFE HEROES!
    http://www.paypal.com/cgi-bin/webscr?cmd=_s-xclick&hosted_button_id=BHMV6P88TGGYE

    4- PRINT FLIERS AND HAND THEM OUT – CHALK ON SIDEWALKS – STOP PASSERBYS
    AND INFORM THEM
    http://nycga.cc/?page_id=226

    5- OFFER WORDS OF SUPPORT AND/OR WATCH LIVE FEEDS RIGHT AT LIBERTY PARK -
    OVER 7000 VIEWERS RIGHT NOW!
    http://www.livestream.com/globalrevolution?utm_source=lsplayer&utm_medium=ui-play&utm_campaign=click-bait&utm_content=globalrevolution

    6- SHARE THIS AD WITH OTHERS ON CRAIGSLIST, FACEBOOK, TWITTER, GOOGLE
    PLUS AND ALL NEWS SITES
    HERE IS A LIST OF ALL NEWSPAPERS IN THE US – http://www.usnpl.com/

    7 – SPONSOR SOMEONE ELSE TO GO TO NYC – OFFER $ TO THEM OR TAKE CARE OF
    THEIR PETS OR WATER THEIR PLANTS….

    8 – DO NOT ARGUE WITH SHEEPLE, JUST SIMPLY IGNORE AND CONTINUE TO SPREAD
    THE WORD. THIS IS ENERGY BETTER USED
    IN POSITIVE WAYS THAN ARGUING WITH THOSE THAT ARE STILL SLEEPING IN LALA
    LAND.

    THANKS – SEE YOU THERE!!!!!!!!ADDITIONAL NOTE:  POLICE
    BRUTALITY AND NON-CONSTITUTIONAL ARRESTS IS HAPPENING EVERY DAY.  CLICK
    THESE LINKS TO WATCH THE VIDEOS!http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kevXKRROF6I

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dyvbI6Eq-qAhttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xmmvZ7z-ZVo

    STAND UP AMERICA!  DO SOMETHING!  COMMON QUESTIONS:1-
    HOW MANY PEOPLE ARE THERE?   There are more and more people every
    day, many are local to NYC and go home to sleep.2- WHERE DO THEY GO
    TO THE BATHROOM?
        There is a 24 hour McDonalds next door to the park.3- HOW DO
    THEY SHOWER?    There are mobile shower units that some have and
    others are using sink baths or baby wipes.4-  WHAT IS THE PURPOSE OF
    THE PROTEST?
         The purpose of the protest is to have our voices heard, it can and
    will become anything you desire it to be.   If you are against logging
    (for example) then your signs will be in regards to this and it will be
    accepted by everyone.   This protest is for anyone and everyone – we are
    the 99%

    SUPPORT – DONATE – JOIN – SUPPORT – DONATE – JOIN – SUPPORT – DONATE

    JOIN – SUPPORT – DONATE – JOIN – SUPPORT – DONATE – JOIN SUPPORT –
    DONATE – JOIN – SUPPORT – DONATE – JOIN – SUPPORT – DONATE –
    JOIN – SUPPORT – DONATE – JOIN – SUPPORT – DONATE – JOIN SUPPORT –
    DONATE – JOIN – SUPPORT – DONATE – JOIN – SUPPORT – DONATE –
    JOIN – SUPPORT – DONATE – JOIN – SUPPORT – DONATE – JOIN SUPPORT –
    DONATE – JOIN – SUPPORT – DONATE – JOIN – SUPPORT – DONATE –
    JOIN – SUPPORT – DONATE – JOIN – SUPPORT – DONATE – JOIN SUPPORT –
    DONATE – JOIN – SUPPORT – DONATE – JOIN – SUPPORT – DONATE –
    JOIN – SUPPORT – DONATE – JOIN – SUPPORT – DONATE – JOIN SUPPORT –
    DONATE – JOIN – SUPPORT – DONATE – JOIN – SUPPORT – DONATE –
    JOIN – SUPPORT – DONATE – JOIN – SUPPORT – DONATE – JOIN

     

  • Anonymous

    http://www.lovetoshopping.org  Cheapest Vans Shoes,Tiffany Jewelry Company,Wholesale Hollister Clothing 

  • didi

    it is a wonder how the NYT journalist does not realize that all said are the issues in the US and that every single movement (and I’ve been part of a successful one in Serbia and recently in Madison WI, which I hope will result in recall of Scott Walker) starts as a very diverse group of unsatisfied people… this group of young people needs to attract middle aged people as Madison protest did… once they reach 100.000 the picture will significantly change…   

  • http://www.facebook.com/trishjw Patricia Wilson

    There may be numerous items that they and I even as old as 70 can agree with but the necessity of organization is required or those you wish to have hear you won’t.  Can you move around GREED, Education for all and health for all as three major topics and illustrate in posters and Youtube presentations what you think is needed by society and/or Congress.  Obama can’t do anything if Congress has mud feet just for the hell of it.  CNN presented you as “Know Nothings” last Friday also and that is no more true than what the NY Times has said.  MSM has problems understanding anything under $80,000 life style.You must show them there and through other advertising through the TV if possible  what you are talking about and that there are reasons for why you are upset and methods to change or improve things.  Many you need to get to do  not have iphones and/or computers that they go to daily.  Most of them are over 35 and they are also the ones that will vote come November 2012.  My relatives have computers and one sells Intel chips but neither have much interest of getting information from the computer.  They get it from TV and major newspapers.  Many of my Midwest cousins are similar.  These are only examples tens of thousands throughout the country that you need to get to and MSM won’t do it without you pushing it in their faces with organized ideas as was done in Wisconsin.  Tea Party gets their time in the news because they are different in perspective–right or wrong.  You mush show that also.

  • http://home.earthlink.net/~jhorne18 Jeremy Horne

    We must start somewhere.  It is arrogant for the the experienced to expect a Ph.D.-level protest, when the victims of this society have been denied a proper education (I mean philosophy, exposure to alternate systems, etc.).  One does not have to be a medical doctor to know that something is wrong with her/his health, and it is the same here.  Yes, it is corporatism and the very ethos underpinning it that is wrong, and a real civilized alternative, such as democratic socialism/cooperativism is a very good option.  However, when people have been steeped in McCarthyism and the “news” from corporatist media and have few cross currents of ideas, what can one expect?  That is changing – a large part to the boundless internet, and as people come out of their cages, they will realize the present regime is not the way it has to be.  It may be no Tahrir Square – YET!  Tomorrow is coming, and the ultrareactionaries will be trembling for a reason.  1789 is upon us.

  • http://www.ucmeta.org/ Metaphysical Sciences

    they’re getting more support and coverge now more than they would have if wall street had just let them do their thing

  • http://www.christinebreese.info/SpiritualPages/UniversityOfMetaphysicalSciences.htm Christine Breese

    That is definitely strange that they aren’t covered in the news at all, what’s up with that?

  • Mary Sweeney

    Grow up. This is not free advertizing space.

  • Mary Sweeney

    The media is playing the role of the black maids in “The Help” minus their courage. Their “mistresses” are the banks and corporations. The media are just standing on the edge of the banquet room as the bankers and corporations tell them what to serve up.  Or, if you want to compare to another book/movie “Sarah’s Key”, the media has chosen the role of  those that turned away at the time of the Vel’ d’Hiv Roundup. Funny how the NY Times reviewed both books positively but apparently do not see the connection.

  • http://home.earthlink.net/~jhorne18 Jeremy Horne

    Mary Sweeney is exactly right.  This type of cheap spamming is part of what the Wall Street demonstrations are all about – commercialism.  Your post is part of the problem, not the solution.

  • guest

    Lol, sure, since socialism has failed in every place it has been tried.  But you are right that many are ignorant, although many went to great colleges.  The problem is that those colleges teach all about the wonders of things like democratic socialism, but not a lot about reality and basic economics  The organizers, however, are professional activists, like Lisa Fithian and Vlad Teichberg, who have tried this in many other countries before this “spontaneous movement” arose.  

    “People will come out of their cages”?  Lol, pedantic to the last, eh? You support them while at the same time calling them ignorant and unable to ennunicate their points.  I suggest you spend some more time learning about reality and the failure you and other organizers push.  

    You’re right this is no Tahrir Square.  Because people in this system that you would like to bash have boundless freedom, even the freedom to sit around in a park and disturb the neighbors and consume millions of tax dollars.  You have the gall to compare this whine to the Egyptians in the square?  And let’s ask what is happening in Tahrir Square now? Do you know?  Or after you agitated for it, don’t you care what resulted?  Coptic Christians are being shot in the streets.  ”Arab Spring” my ass.

    When you push for revolution, but have no idea how to deal with what comes next, you get chaos.  And that is what is happening everywhere your “1789″ crew is working.

    Let’s not forget the three deaths you are responsible for in Greece, when the mobs unleashed by the organizers attacked and burnt a bank last year, trapping three people inside, suffocating them to death. Wow, a blow against the evil capitalists.

    1789, in case people missed it, is Jeremy Horne, PhD’s call for a revolution, a la the French Revolution.  

    It’s not happening, buddy.

  • http://home.earthlink.net/~jhorne18 Jeremy Horne

    In your reactionary screed you failed to mention that one of my main critiques is the anarchy in all this. I cannot think of any case where anarchy has solved anything, and, yes, I am aware of the many types of anarchy. The failure to have a platform and organization to supplant Mubarak is the reason you see what is happening today. I repeatedly have said that there must be a programme, education, organization, discipline, as well as action.  Of course, many processes are not linear but take shape as they develop.  I cll for democratic socialism, but I suspect that you haven’t read much of the literature, or else you wouldn’t be spouting so much red scare propaganda to the delight of the Koch Brothers and other corporatists.  Of course you’d never criticize socialist for the rich, would you, or the military, the members of which are IN a socialist institution, where they are wet nursed from cradle to gave.  but, I suspect you’d never criticize that.

    As to the “boundless freedom”, as how much “freedom” (which you have no idea about freedom and liberty), people have without a job and being broke, the lack of health care, and inability to relocate to even look for work.  The fact is, if you come out your reactionary cocoon that there ARE no jobs.  Instead, we have the financial elites that have ripped off the government, workers, and are continuing to gut any resources that are left.  Your freedom is hollow; it is empty; it is an ideological catch word to justify corporatism.  Freedom IS anarchy.  Liberty, of which John Locke wrote so eloquently about does allow more of that freedom about which you rave on about so inanely.  Read the Second Treatise of Civil Government.

    As to the violence you say has been perpetrated by the demonstrators, not to justify it, but you’d better look at the violence unleashed by imperialist wars, the torture chambers of Abu Ghraib, and the innocent people hit by Predator drones.

    You say that I have no idea of how to deal with what follows.  This is predicated upon people having that plan, etc., as mentioned above.  Socialism  has not necessarily failed but has been attacked by reactionaries who will not permit it to work.

Abrams Media Network click here for advertising opportunities

© 2013 The Jane Dough | About Us | Advertise | Newsletter | Privacy | User Agreement | Disclaimer | Contact | Archives | Send a Tip | RSS RSS
Dan Abrams, Founder | Hosting by Datagram

X