1. Mediaite
  2. Gossip Cop
  3. Geekosystem
  4. Styleite
  5. SportsGrid
  6. The Mary Sue
  7. The Jane Dough
  8. The Braiser

TV

Sarah Jessica Parker ‘Glee’ Appearance An Epic Disappointment


Just three episodes in, season four of Ryan Murphy’s “Glee” has had an impressive lineup of guest actors. All right, there have only been two celebrities of note — Sarah Jessica Parker and Kate Hudson — but audience members everywhere expected these two to move mountains. Hudson does that in episodes one and two. SJP, who appears in last night’s installment of “Glee,” misses the mark, which is bizarre if nothing else because of her long-run as New York City savant Carrie Bradshaw in “Sex and the City.”

It likely that Murphy wanted SJP’s “Glee” character, a Vogue.com editor named Isabelle, to parallel Bradshaw. It’s tough not to compare the two, as SJP is most well known for her SATC persona, but in the teenage world of “Glee,” it’s important to keep things PG-13. That’s what Isabelle does, and sadly it doesn’t work.

Fresh-from-Ohio high school graduate, Kurt takes on an internship at the fashion website, which is a mess the moment he starts his position. Having looked up to Isabelle for much of his life, Kurt is excited to work under her, and perhaps even more thrilled to serve as her personal therapist. Isabelle goes on and on about how inadequate she is, stating she’s going to lose her job and apartment. Everyone who comes to NYC has a similar freak out at some point, and reassurance from others rarely helps. Isabelle appreciates that she and Kurt grew up in the same state, but is horrified when he promises she never has to be homeless: “You can always come stay with me and my roommate in Bushwick.” Not happening.

It’s incredibly unrealistic to believe that a high-profile Condé Nast editor would confide in an 18-year-old intern or turn said volunteer into her new BFF right away merely because they share similar roots. At another point in the episode, Kurt and bestie Rachel break into the Vogue offices so Rachel can have a makeover and perform in a music video. Isabelle catches them, and rather than give Kurt the boot as a professional would, she asks to join in on the fun and partake in the music video. We get the impression she is a lot of fun and not your typical stuffy Vogue staffer, but who could honestly envision such a response on her end? No boss is that laid back, especially with regards to rule-breaking interns.

“Glee” could have done a lot more with SJP’s role rather than have her essentially echo Bradshaw and pull a series of unrealistic moves. Just be thankful she only signed on for one episode this season.

TAGS: |

  • Anonymous
  • Anonymous

    This is a show that used a kid in a wheelchair as a battering ram in a football game and you’re concerned that it’s unrealistic a Conde Nast editor would confide in an intern? LOL!

  • http://twitter.com/LauraDonovanUA Laura Donovan

    What does this sentence mean? “you’re concerned that it’s unrealistic a Conde Nast editor would confide in an intern?”

  • Anonymous

    Apparently, it means I read the article above and you didn’t.

  • http://twitter.com/LauraDonovanUA Laura Donovan

    actually your sentence has typos so until you can provide me with one that makes sense, I have no idea what you’re trying to say.

  • Anonymous

    Do you know what a typo is? There’s not a single typo either of the posts above.

  • http://twitter.com/LauraDonovanUA Laura Donovan

    It’s awkwardly worded, but I understand what you’re saying. I agree that Glee isn’t a realistic program to begin with, but I found the SJP appearance to be particularly ridiculous. There are plenty more examples like this on the show.

  • Anonymous

    Let me see if I can clear this up for you.

    “It’s incredibly unrealistic to believe that a high-profile Condé Nast
    editor would confide in an 18-year-old intern or turn said volunteer
    into her new BFF right away merely because they share similar roots.”

    That’s a quote from your article. My point is that if you’re expecting any kind of realism from Glee, you’re may want to change those expectations. After all, this is a show that once used a kid in a wheelchair as a human battering ram during a football game. It’s also a show where the various vocal groups they compete against seem to change districts and conferences on a whim. Not exactly realistic.

  • http://twitter.com/LauraDonovanUA Laura Donovan

    I get what you’re saying, I just found THIS example to be particularly absurd. Guess I should have expected it.

  • Benny

    I don’t like Glee.Never have.Hate that show.The music part is very good though,and Jane Lynch is obviously awesome.I get what they’re trying to do,but overall it suuucks!

    Aaaaahh….there,I said it.I feel so much better now.

    *drink*

  • http://twitter.com/LauraDonovanUA Laura Donovan

    I adore Jane Lynch but some aspects of the show could really use some ironing out. I worry it’s a lost cause four seasons in, though. I do, however, appreciate that it addresses the problem of school bullying. I wish there’d been a show like that around while I was in middle school. Lizzie McGuire just didn’t cut it because her character was so incredibly ditzy and shallow, and I found her OMG SHOPPING attitude to be really hard to relate to.

  • Morgan Flag

    It likely that Murphy wanted SJP’s “Glee” character, a Vogue.com
    editor named Isabelle, to parallel Bradshaw. It’s tough not to compare
    the two, as SJP is most well known for her SATC persona, but in the
    teenage world of “Glee,” it’s important to keep things PG-13. That’s
    what Isabelle does, and sadly it doesn’t work.
    http://www.bluegala.com

Abrams Media Network click here for advertising opportunities

© 2013 The Jane Dough | About Us | Advertise | Newsletter | Privacy | User Agreement | Disclaimer | Contact | Archives | Send a Tip | RSS RSS
Dan Abrams, Founder | Hosting by Datagram

X